Cher Thompson is a Senior Staff Writer at Screen Rant, where she covers everything from explosive reality TV moments to cast interviews about the twists and turns of scripted dramas. With a background in creative writing, marketing, and teaching, Cher knows how to spot both the storytelling genius and the guilty pleasures in pop culture. Her work blends wit with insight, making readers feel like they’re chatting with a friend who just happens to know way too much about TV.
While Yellowstone spent years developing the conflict between the Dutton family and Broken Rock Reservation, Marshals is approaching things differently, with the series currently teasing a potential shift in power. Throughout Yellowstone's run, Thomas Rainwater (Gil Birmingham) was positioned as an adversary to John Dutton (Kevin Costner), but his motivations surrounding the land Dutton Ranch sat on were clear. With hopes to reclaim the land that belonged to his people, Rainwater was someone who worked against the Duttons, but had personal motivations that viewers could understand throughout the run of the series. Even so, Rainwater wasn't always positioned as a villain.
Instead, the series made it clear that Rainwater's perspective was different from the Dutton family, not lesser. When the original series culminated in the sale of the majority of Dutton Ranch to Broken Rock on the condition that it not be developed or sold, Yellowstone made it clear that the series was ironing out the longstanding plot, and keeping Rainwater at the heart of the story. As Marshals has continued, with Rainwater moving to the CBS spinoff along with Kayce Dutton (Luke Grimes), the story of Broken Rock has continued, albeit in a somewhat less nuanced way than in the original series.
Even so, with Marshals keeping Broken Rock in the picture, Rainwater has remained a big part of the franchise's DNA. Marshals season 2 has been developing its Broken Rock plot, and with consequences landing on Rainwater's doorstep, the threat to his position within the Broken Rock community is more pressing than ever.
Throughout the run of Yellowstone, Rainwater's position was defined by his determination to reclaim land that was rightfully owned by the people of Broken Rock. Spending much of his time on the original series fighting John Dutton and the rest of the family, Rainwater found himself at odds with the family's interests, which made him appear like an antagonist for the show as a whole. The relationship between Rainwater and the Dutton family did evolve eventually, and though things were in a better place during the series finale, the history of conflict between the Duttons and Rainwater has brought an interesting dynamic into Marshals.
With the CBS spinoff series exploring Kayce's life after the transfer of the Dutton Ranch, there's somewhat less spotlight to shine on Broken Rock, but what does find itself gaining traction on Marshals is Rainwater's standing and leadership. Throughout the first episodes of Marshals season 2, the spinoff series has been exploring Rainwater's leadership after the victory of finally reclaiming Broken Rock. Having spent years acquiring the land, the people of Broken Rock are now questioning if Rainwater is the right fit to lead their community in these new circumstances, and have pushed back with increasing force throughout Marshals season 2.
With the intensity of the fight against Rainwater growing more traction, Marshals is exploring a whole different side of the conflict. A meaningful departure from the way Rainwater's character functioned throughout Yellowstone's run, the push against Broken Rock's leader has been an intense shift.
With the CBS series leaning into the conflict between Rainwater and his people, there have been contenders that have come out of the woodwork to potentially take on the challenge of leading Broken Rock in this new era. Shane Whitebear (Duke Davis Roberts) has been one of the names that's cut through the noise on Marshals as a potential challenger to Rainwater's leadership. With the series establishing that Shane plans to run against the chairman of Broken Rock, Marshals season 2 has found a formidable opponent for Rainwater as someone who feels like they're more aware of the people's needs, wants, and issues.
While Shane was only introduced during Marshals season 2 episode 3, "Falling Sky," the series saw him quickly enter the ring as one of Rainwater's most formidable opponents. His personal disagreement with how Rainwater dealt with issues surrounding Broken Rock, specifically the possibility of opening a cannabis farm on the reservation, led to deeper conversations about his potential for leadership. In the span of a few episodes, it became clear that Shane and Rainwater had come to an agreement, making it clear that Shane had some ability to argue his case with the current chairman and make valid points.
Shane is definitely a credible challenger for Rainwater, even if his political career hasn't spanned decades like the chairman's. Though Shane hasn't established himself as a leader for Broken Rock yet, he's taking the chance to prove himself in everyday situations, which could make his threat even stronger to Rainwater's leadership.
While Shane poses a threat to Rainwater's leadership, it doesn't seem likely for Marshals to allow that threat to take over completely, if only because of Rainwater's connection to Yellowstone and Kayce specifically. The Rainwater story in Marshals season 2 may be independent of the Kayce story, but the two characters converge more than viewers may expect, and keeping both in the loop is tantamount to Marshals' success. The relationship between Kayce and Rainwater has been in development since Yellowstone, and knowing that Kayce currently lives on the only remaining piece of Dutton Ranch that the family was allowed to keep, their connection is still strong.
The relationship between Kayce and Rainwater may be sparse, but it still matters for Marshals as a series. Keeping Kayce aligned with someone who also came from Yellowstone may not seem like an important element of the series, but for Marshals to function as a part of the greater Yellowstone universe, it has to retain some pieces of the original series. Rainwater has stepped in as somewhat of a surrogate parent for Kayce throughout the CBS show's run, and the connection the two share to the original series keeps the connection of the spinoff alive.
With their relationship standing strong an important part of keeping Marshals' tether to Yellowstone alive, replacing Rainwater as the chairman of Broken Rock doesn't feel like the best move for the spinoff series. Instead, allowing Rainwater to shift his perspective and regain favor with his people would allow for a strong story that doesn't rattle Marshals at its foundation.
